BOOKS OF THE MONTH Abundance Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson Avid Reader Press, 297 pages Published March 18, 2025The cover image of Abundance says it all: it depicts the planet, cut open to reveal a city of futuristic skyscrapers, surrounded by verdant fields of crops and solar panels. Just past a flowing stream, a majestic deer is surrounded by a “rewilded” forest, as tropical birds fly overhead. A Utopian fantasy? Journalists Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson think not. This could be our future, they posit, if we “build and invent more of what we need.” It’s that simple … and that difficult. Instead, America’s story is that of “chosen scarcities,” an outcome “coproduced by both parties and reinforced by their leaders” that government cannot solve our country’s problems. Instead, the authors sketch a vision of an abundant future in which long-time Americans and immigrants alike flourish, and the planet is sustained. Abundance is equal parts hopeful and discouraging; the authors detail failed project after program after policy at both the state and federal levels. Many well-intentioned requirements (e.g., insisting on environmental studies, requiring multiple bids, and ensuring that women and minorities are included) cost time and money that hamper government efforts. Everything takes longer and costs more than anticipated — and audacious plans such as high-speed rail in California never come to fruition. They learn from emergencies, such as Operation Warp Speed (development and implementation of a COVID vaccine) or Pennsylvania’s response under Governor Josh Shapiro to rebuild an essential bridge on I-95 in 12 days rather than months. Drawing upon these examples, the authors show what government can achieve when it gets out of its way. In our current climate, it’s hard to imagine elected officials from either party taking Abundance seriously. The non-partisan authors critique both/all sides, accusing conservatives of intentionally undermining government effectiveness and progressives of “everything-bagel liberalism,” a tendency to pile so many standards and rules into a bill until it collapses under its weight rather than accomplish its goals. Abundance offers hope, an alternative lens through which to evaluate issues, and “a new set of questions around which our politics should revolve.” Churches and community leaders will find Klein and Thompson to be faithful conversation partners in seeking a better way forward and identifying issues on which to focus. |
No comments:
Post a Comment